Make Me a Mixtape

* Libro.fm ALC Review *

Make Me a Mixtape by Jennifer Whiteford is a heartfelt and quirky story that hits all the right notes. The characters are wonderfully unique, each bringing something special to the narrative. Their journeys of self-discovery and learning to see life through a new perspective were both relatable and inspiring.

The use of music as a way of connecting was beautifully done—it wasn’t just a backdrop but a meaningful thread that tied the story and the characters together. The found family dynamic was incredibly touching, showing how love and support can come from the most unexpected places. Watching the characters embrace their individuality added an uplifting layer to the story.

At the heart of it all is the endearing love connection between Allie and Ryan. Their chemistry is both sweet and genuine, and their shared love of music adds depth to their bond. Their relationship grows naturally, filled with moments of humor, vulnerability, and heartwarming support. Combined with the witty banter and the overarching themes of connection, Make Me a Mixtape is a celebration of finding yourself, your people, and your place in the world.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/ 4.5

🌶️/ 1.5

Blurb:

A guarded punk-rocker-turned-barista meets a big-hearted sound tech who charms his way into her life and helps her revisit her musical past in this truly charming, cozy fall romance.

Allie Andrews gave up on the music world ten years ago. No wild tours, no late nights, no career-ending inter-band blowouts. Just day after comfortable day of working in her aunt’s café in Brooklyn and recording ’80s cover songs in her tiny apartment. The last thing she wants, or expects, is to be recognized as former punk rocker Allie Jetski. But a last-minute coffee delivery lands her face to face with the big, charming, handsome (and quite possibly number one fan of the Jetskis) Ryan Abernathy.

Ryan isn’t about to forget meeting the lead singer of one of his favorite bands. Undeterred by her prickly demeanor, he sets his mind to helping Allie find her way back to the Jetskis—so she can come to terms with what happened all those years ago. Allie finds Ryan hard to resist, and her quiet life is turned upside down as she is swept up in a whirlwind hunt for her old bandmates.

But when Aunt Mindy announces that she’s decided to sell the café, Allie is faced with a life-altering choice: play it safe and take over the business, or risk opening herself up to a future in music . . . and maybe even love.

XOXO, Courtney